Tear-Off: The removal of all existing roof covering, and often the underlayment, down to the roof deck before new roofing is installed.
What a Tear-Off Is
In a tear-off the roofer strips every layer of old shingles, the underlayment and the old flashing down to the plywood or boards of the roof deck. It is the standard way to replace a roof, as opposed to a roof-over, which lays new shingles on top of the old ones.
On a quote you may see it as tear-off and disposal, strip and haul or full replacement. The price usually includes the dumpster, magnet sweeps for nails and cleanup. A tear-off is also the moment the roof's real condition becomes visible: soft spots, old leaks, missing flashing and undersized ventilation are all found here, and each one can change the scope, the cost and sometimes the permit.
The Two-Layer Limit and When Tear-Off Is Required
The model residential code (IRC) generally allows new roofing to go over only one existing layer, so a roof with two layers must be torn off, and tear-off is typically also required when the existing roofing is water-soaked, damaged or of a type that cannot take a second layer, such as wood shakes or slate in many cases. Local adoption varies, and some cities set stricter rules.
Even where you could roof over, many roofers recommend a tear-off because it exposes rotted decking and gives the new roof a clean base. Insurance companies and shingle manufacturers may also prefer it for warranty terms, so check both before choosing a shortcut.
Why a Bare Deck Matters to the Permit
A tear-off exposes the sheathing, and replacing even part of it is the point at which many cities require a permit for what would otherwise be an exempt reroof. Where a city requires a deck or underlayment inspection, the best time for the inspector is while the deck is bare and before the underlayment goes down, so ask your roofer to schedule it.
If the crew finds rot, the permit may have to cover the added repair, and a structural repair can bring in plan review. Ask your roofer whether the contract covers a per-sheet price for replacement decking, and whether the permit will be updated if the scope grows.
Where Tear-Offs Come Up on This Site
Our research on replacing a roof found that a like-for-like tear-off and reshingle needs no permit in 16 of the 30 largest U.S. cities we cover and does in 14. In 10 cities, replacing any sheathing or decking brings a permit in. Fees are compared on the roof permit fee page, where the city's own example runs from a few dozen dollars to over a thousand. A permit is also where the city checks the nailing, underlayment and flashing the crew will install. The full process is in the roof replacement guide.